Statistical Review of Major Standpoints in Hydraulic Transient-Based Leak Detection

Document Type: Research Paper

Authors

1 Department of Civil Engineering, Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz, Ahvaz, Iran

2 Department of Civil and Natural Resources Engineering, University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand

Abstract

Today, pipe systems are the most common facilities to convey various fluids from one place to another. In such facilities faults like leaks lead to advert consequences such as economic losses and social health threats. The fact that early detection of leaks can play a prominent role in reducing the amount of these undesired impacts has absorbed noticeable attention from researchers to this field of study. This paper presents a literature review on major aspects of hydraulic transient-based leak detection in pipe systems over the past three decades. The value of the present study is that an extensive database of peer-reviewed publications is brought together under a meticulous survey. It describes the trends, status and pinpoints the areas with a need for further investigation in the future. Uniquely, it contains information for over 95 publications in a tabular form, presenting domain type, analysis approach, optimization technique, topographic complexity of the case study, leak unknowns and validation approach.

Keywords


  1. Vitkovsky , J.P., et al., Optimal Measurement Site Locations for Inverse Transient Analysis in Pipe Networks. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 2003. 129(6): p. 480-492.
  2. Ghazali, M.F., et al., Instantaneous phase and frequency for the detection of leaks and features in a pipeline system. Structural Health Monitoring, 2010. 10(4): p. 351-360.
  3. Liggett James, A. and L.C. Chen, Inverse Transient Analysis in Pipe Networks. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 1994. 120(8): p. 934-955.
  4. Brunone, B., Transient test-based technique for leak detection in outfall pipes. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 1999. 125(5): p. 302–306.
  5. Nash, G.A. and B.W. Karney, Efficient inverse transient analysis in series pipe systems. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 1999. 125(7): p. 761–764.
  6. Vítkovský John, P., R. Simpson Angus, and F. Lambert Martin, Leak Detection and Calibration Using Transients and Genetic Algorithms. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 2000. 126(4): p. 262-265.
  7. Brunone, B. and M. Ferrante, Detecting leaks in pressurised pipes by means of transients. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2001. 39(5): p. 539-547.
  8. Covas, D.a.R., H. , Hydraulic transients used for leakage detection in water distribution systems, in 4th Intl. Conf, Water pipline system. 2001: York UK. p. 227-241.
  9. Vítkovský, J.P., A.R. Simpson, and M.F. Lambert, Minimization algorithms and experimental inverse transient leak detection, in Conference on Water Resources Planning and Management (2002 : Roanoke, Virginia, USA). 2002.
  10. Kapelan, Z.S., D.A. Savic, and G.A. Walters, A hybrid inverse transient model for leakage detection and roughness calibration in pipe networks. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2003. 41(5): p. 481-492.
  11. Vítkovský John, P., et al., Experimental Observation and Analysis of Inverse Transients for Pipeline Leak Detection. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 2007. 133(6): p. 519-530.
  12. Nixon, W. and S. Ghidaoui Mohamed, Numerical Sensitivity Study of Unsteady Friction in Simple Systems with External Flows. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2007. 133(7): p. 736-749.
  13. Al-Khomairi, A., Leak detection in long pipelines using the least squares method. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2008. 46(3): p. 392-401.
  14. Jung, B.S. and B.W. Karney, Systematic exploration of pipeline network calibration using transients. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2008. 46(sup1): p. 129-137.
  15. Shamloo, H. and A. Haghighi, Leak detection in pipelines by inverse backward transient analysis. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2009. 47(3): p. 311-318.
  16. Torres, L., G. Besançon, and D. Georges. Multi-leak estimator for pipelines based on an orthogonal collocation model. in Decision and Control, 2009 held jointly with the 2009 28th Chinese Control Conference. CDC/CCC 2009. Proceedings of the 48th IEEE Conference on. 2009. IEEE.
  17. Covas, D. and H. Ramos, Case Studies of Leak Detection and Location in Water Pipe Systems by Inverse Transient Analysis. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 2010. 136(2): p. 248–257.
  18. Shamloo, H. and A. Haghighi, Optimum leak detection and calibration of pipe networks by inverse transient analysis. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2010. 48(3): p. 371-376.
  19. Soares, A.K., D.I.C. Covas, and L.F.R. Reis, Leak detection by inverse transient analysis in an experimental PVC pipe system. Journal of Hydroinformatics, 2011. 13(2): p. 153.
  20. Haghighi, A., D. Covas, and H. Ramos, Direct backward transient analysis for leak detection in pressurized pipelines: from theory to real application. Journal of Water Supply: Research and Technology - Aqua, 2012. 61(3): p. 189-200.
  21. Haghighi, A. and A. Keramat, A fuzzy approach for considering uncertainty in transient analysis of pipe networks. Journal of Hydroinformatics, 2012. 14(4): p. 1024-1035.
  22. Zecchin Aaron, C., F. Lambert Martin, and R. Simpson Angus, Inverse Laplace Transform for Transient-State Fluid Line Network Simulation. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 2012. 138(1): p. 101-115.
  23. Huang, Y.-C., C.-C. Lin, and H.-D. Yeh, An Optimization Approach to Leak Detection in Pipe Networks Using Simulated Annealing. Water Resources Management, 2015. 29(11): p. 4185-4201.
  24. Rahmanshahi, M., M. Fathi-Moghadam, and A. Haghighi, Leak Detection in Viscoelastic Pipeline using Inverse Transient Analysis. 2017.
  25. Kim, S.H., Extensive development of leak detection algorithm by impulse response method. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2005. 131(3): p. 201-208.
  26. Mpesha, W., L. Gassman Sarah, and M.H. Chaudhry, Leak Detection in Pipes by Frequency Response Method. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2001. 127(2): p. 134-147.
  27. Lee, P.J., et al. Leak detection in pipelines using an inverse resonance method. in 2002 Conference on Water Resources Planning & Management. 2002.
  28. Ferrante, M. and B. Brunone, Pipe system diagnosis and leak detection by unsteady-state tests. 1. Harmonic analysis. Advances in Water Resources, 2003. 26(1): p. 95-105.
  29. Lee, P.J., et al., Leak location using the pattern of the frequency response diagram in pipelines: a numerical study. Journal of Sound and Vibration, 2005a. 284(3): p. 1051-1073.
  30. Covas, D., H. Ramos, and A.B. De Almeida, Standing wave difference method for leak detection in pipeline systems. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2005. 131(12): p. 1106-1116.
  31. Lee, P.J., et al., Frequency Domain Analysis for Detecting Pipeline Leaks. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2005b. 131(7): p. 596-604.
  32. Lee, P.J., et al., Experimental verification of the frequency response method for pipeline leak detection. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2006. 44(5): p. 693-707.
  33. Sattar, A.M. and M.H. Chaudhry, Leak detection in pipelines by frequency response method. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2008. 46(sup1): p. 138-151.
  34. Zecchin Aaron, C., et al., Transient Modeling of Arbitrary Pipe Networks by a Laplace-Domain Admittance Matrix. Journal of Engineering Mechanics, 2009. 135(6): p. 538-547.
  35. Lee Pedro, J. and P. Vítkovský John, Quantifying Linearization Error When Modeling Fluid Pipeline Transients Using the Frequency Response Method. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2010. 136(10): p. 831-836.
  36. Duan, H.-F., et al., Leak detection in complex series pipelines by using the system frequency response method. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2011. 49(2): p. 213-221.
  37. Vítkovský John, P., et al., Head- and Flow-Based Formulations for Frequency Domain Analysis of Fluid Transients in Arbitrary Pipe Networks. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2011. 137(5): p. 556-568.
  38. Duan, H.-F., et al., System Response Function–Based Leak Detection in Viscoelastic Pipelines. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2012. 138(2): p. 143-153.
  39. Guo, X., K. Yang, and Y. Guo, Leak detection in pipelines by exclusively frequency domain method. Science China Technological Sciences, 2012. 55(3): p. 743-752.
  40. Gong, J., et al., Single-Event Leak Detection in Pipeline Using First Three Resonant Responses. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2013. 139(6): p. 645-655.
  41. Lee, P.J., Energy analysis for the illustration of inaccuracies in the linear modelling of pipe fluid transients. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2013. 51(2): p. 133-144.
  42. Gong, J., et al., Frequency Response Diagram for Pipeline Leak Detection: Comparing the Odd and Even Harmonics. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management, 2014. 140(1): p. 65-74.
  43. Kim Sang, H., A. Zecchin, and L. Choi, Diagnosis of a Pipeline System for Transient Flow in Low Reynolds Number with Impedance Method. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2014. 140(12): p. 04014063.
  44. Duan, H.F. and P.J. Lee, Transient-Based Frequency Domain Method for Dead-End Side Branch Detection in Reservoir Pipeline-Valve Systems. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2016. 142(2): p. 04015042.
  45. Ranginkaman, M.H., A. Haghighi, and H.M. Vali Samani, INVERSE FREQUENCY RESPONSE ANALYSIS FOR PIPELINES LEAK DETECTION USING THE PARTICLE SWARM OPTIMIZATION. IUST, 2016. 6(1): p. 1-12.
  46. Rubio Scola, I., G. Besançon, and D. Georges, Blockage and Leak Detection and Location in Pipelines Using Frequency Response Optimization. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2017. 143(1): p. 04016074.
  47. Kim, S.H., Multiple Leakage Function for a Simple Pipeline System. Water Resources Management, 2017. 31(9): p. 2659-2673.
  48. Ranginkaman, M.H., A. Haghighi, and H.M.V. Samani, Application of the Frequency Response Method for Transient Flow Analysis of Looped Pipe Networks. International Journal of Civil Engineering, 2017. 15(4): p. 677-687.
  49. Sabzkouhi, A.M. and A. Haghighi, Uncertainty Analysis of Transient Flow in Water Distribution Networks. Water Resources Management, 2018.
  50. Ferrante, M. and B. Brunone, Pipe system diagnosis and leak detection by unsteady-state tests. 2. Wavelet analysis. Advances in Water Resources, 2003. 26(1): p. 107-116.
  51. Beck, S.B.M., J. Foong, and W.J. Staszewski. Wavelet and Cepstrum Analyses of Leaks in Pipe Networks. in Progress in Industrial Mathematics at ECMI 2004. 2006. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg.
  52. Taghvaei, M., S.B.M. Beck, and W.J. Staszewski, Leak detection in pipelines using cepstrum analysis. Measurement Science and Technology, 2006. 17(2): p. 367.
  53. Lee, P.J., et al., Leak location in single pipelines using transient reflections. Australasian Journal of Water Resources, 2007. 11(1): p. 53-65.
  54. Taghvaei, M., S. Beck, and W. Staszewski, Leak detection in pipeline networks using low‚Äźprofile piezoceramic transducers. Structural Control and Health Monitoring, 2007. 14(8): p. 1063-1082.
  55. Ferrante, M., B. Brunone, and S. Meniconi, Leak detection in branched pipe systems coupling wavelet analysis and a Lagrangian model. Journal of Water Supply: Research and Technology - Aqua, 2009. 58(2): p. 95.
  56. Srirangarajan, S., et al., Wavelet-based Burst Event Detection and Localization in Water Distribution Systems. Journal of Signal Processing Systems, 2012. 72(1): p. 1-16.
  57. Amin, M.M., A. Hadi, and M.F. Ghazali, Leakage Detection in Pipeline Using Synchrosqueeze Wavelet Transform. Applied Mechanics and Materials, 2014. 465-466: p. 467-471.
  58. Hanafi.M.Yusop, et al., Improvement of Cepstrum Analysis for the Purpose to Detect Leak, Feature and Its Location in Water Distribution System based on Pressure Transient Analysis. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2017. 4(4): p. 103-122.
  59. Stephens, M.L., et al., Field Tests for Leakage, Air Pocket, and Discrete Blockage Detection Using Inverse Transient Analysis in Water Distribution Pipes, in 6th Annual Symposium on Water Distribution Systems Analysis. 2004, American Society of Civil Engineers: Salt Lake City, Utah, USA.
  60. Haghighi, A. and H.M. Ramos, Detection of Leakage Freshwater and Friction Factor Calibration in Drinking Networks Using Central Force Optimization. Water Resources Management, 2012. 26(8): p. 2347-2363.
  61. Kim, S., Inverse Transient Analysis for a Branched Pipeline System with Leakage and Blockage Using Impedance Method. Procedia Engineering, 2014. 89: p. 1350-1357.
  62. Lee Pedro, J., et al., Numerical and Experimental Study on the Effect of Signal Bandwidth on Pipe Assessment Using Fluid Transients. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2015. 141(2): p. 04014074.
  63. Wang, X.-J., et al., Leak Detection in Pipelines using the Damping of Fluid Transients. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2002. 128(7): p. 697-711.
  64. Duan, H.-F., et al., Essential system response information for transient-based leak detection methods. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2010. 48(5): p. 650-657.
  65. Kashima, A., P.J. Lee, and R. Nokes, Numerical errors in discharge measurements using the KDP method. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2012. 50(1): p. 98-104.
  66. Lee, P.J., et al., The effect of time–frequency discretization on the accuracy of the transmission line modelling of fluid transients. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2013. 51(3): p. 273-283.
  67. Duan, H.-F., Transient frequency response based leak detection in water supply pipeline systems with branched and looped junctions. Journal of Hydroinformatics, 2016.
  68. Ferrante, M., et al., Numerical transient analysis of random leakage in time and frequency domains. Civil Engineering and Environmental Systems, 2016. 33(1): p. 70-84.
  69. Priemer, R., Introductory Signal Processing. Advanced Series in Electrical and Computer Engineering. Vol. Volume 6. 1990: WORLD SCIENTIFIC. 752.
  70. Sengupta, N., M. Sahidullah, and G. Saha, Lung sound classification using cepstral-based statistical features. Computers in Biology and Medicine, 2016. 75: p. 118-129.
  71. Oppenheim, A.V. and R.W. Schafer, Digital Time-Signal Proccessing. 1998, Upper Saddle River, NJ, USA: Prentice-Hall Inc.
  72. Salvatore, B., et al., Leak detection in liquefied gas pipelines by artificial neural networks. AIChE Journal, 1998. 44(12): p. 2675-2688.
  73. Liou, C.P., Pipeline Leak Detection by Impulse Response Extraction. Journal of Fluids Engineering, 1998. 120(4): p. 833-838.
  74. Motazedi, N. and S. Beck, Leak detection using cepstrum of cross-correlation of transient pressure wave signals. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C: Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science, 2017: p. 0954406217722805.
  75. Al-Shidhani, I., S. Beck, and W. Staszewski. Leak monitoring in pipeline networks using wavelet analysis. in Key engineering materials. 2003. Trans Tech Publ.
  76. Brunone, B. and M. Ferrante, Pressure waves as a tool for leak detection in closed conduits. Urban Water Journal, 2004. 1(2): p. 145-155.
  77. Ferrante, M., B. Brunone, and S. Meniconi, Wavelets for the Analysis of Transient Pressure Signals for Leak Detection. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2007. 133(11): p. 1274-1282.
  78. Ferrante, M., B. Brunone, and S. Meniconi, Leak-edge detection. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2009. 47(2): p. 233-241.
  79. Hu, J., L. Zhang, and W. Liang, Detection of small leakage from long transportation pipeline with complex noise. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, 2011. 24(4): p. 449-457.
  80. Meniconi, S., et al., Small Amplitude Sharp Pressure Waves to Diagnose Pipe Systems. Water Resources Management, 2011. 25(1): p. 79-96.
  81. Hamat, A.M., M.F. Ghazali, and G. Priyandoko, The Use of Transmission Line Modelling for Detection of Leakage in Pipeline. Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2017. 4(4): p. 74-83.
  82. Ghazali, M., et al., Comparative study of instantaneous frequency based methods for leak detection in pipeline networks. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 2012. 29: p. 187-200.
  83. Wang, X. and M.S. Ghidaoui, Identification of multiple leaks in pipeline: Linearized model, maximum likelihood, and super-resolution localization. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 2018. 107: p. 529-548.
  84. Zecchin, A.C., et al., Parameter identification of fluid line networks by frequency-domain maximum likelihood estimation. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 2013. 37(1): p. 370-387.
  85. Wang, X. and M. Ghidaoui, Pipeline leak detection using the matched-field processing method. 2017.
  86. Jönsson, L. and M. Larson, Leak detection through hydraulic transient analysis. In Pipeline Systems 1992, Springer. p. 273–286.
  87. Haghighi, A. and H. Shamloo, Transient generation in pipe networks for leak detection. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Water Management, 2011. 164(6): p. 311-318.
  88. Vitkovsky, J., et al., Leak blockage detection in pipelines via an impulse response method, in Pumps, Electromechanical Devices and Systems Applied to Urban Water Management, E. Cabrera and E.C. Jr, Editors. 2003, A.A. Balkema Publishers: Lisse, The Netherelands. p. 423–430.
  89. Lee Pedro, J., et al., Valve Design for Extracting Response Functions from Hydraulic Systems Using Pseudorandom Binary Signals. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2008. 134(6): p. 858-864.
  90. Bartecki, K., Frequency-and time-domain analysis of a simple pipeline system. IFAC Proceedings Volumes, 2009. 42(13): p. 366-371.
  91. Gong, J., et al., Determination of the linear frequency response of single pipelines using persistent transient excitation: a numerical investigation. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2013. 51(6): p. 728-734.
  92. Lee, P.J., et al., Leak location in pipelines using the impulse response function. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2007. 45(5): p. 643-652.
  93. Kim, S.H., Development of Multiple Leakage Detection Method for a Reservoir Pipeline Valve System. Water Resources Management, 2018. 32(6): p. 2099-2112.
  94. Mpesha, W., M. Hanif Chaudhry, and S.L. Gassman, Leak detection in pipes by frequency response method using a step excitation. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2002. 40(1): p. 55-62.
  95. Beck, S.B., et al., Pipeline Network Features and Leak Detection by Cross-Correlation Analysis of Reflected Waves. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2005. 131(8): p. 715-723.
  96. Nixon, W., M.S. Ghidaoui, and A.A. Kolyshkin, Range of Validity of the Transient Damping Leakage Detection Method. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2006. 132(9): p. 944-957.
  97. Duan, H.-F., et al., Unsteady friction and visco-elasticity in pipe fluid transients. Journal of Hydraulic Research, 2010. 48(3): p. 354-362.
  98. Duan, H.F., et al., Relevance of Unsteady Friction to Pipe Size and Length in Pipe Fluid Transients. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 2012. 138(2): p. 154-166.